Battle for Middle Earth

i wil review for my third app

expect it later today or tonight probably

Great game by Tommynt. Too bad about the EW-mistakes for high rating.

land and ew give 40% defence and cancel wc(50% attack and defence)

hm. Never thought about it that way because warchant is temporary and land is permanent. but maybe you're right.

place land, cancel wc, retreat to a place without land

mine as noone wants to review it
hehe
I'll start with the older replays

review by Stone


[NOON]Grenness vs tommynt
map: Fords of Isen
version: 1.03




[NOON]Grenness

start: Merry, 2 inner farms, 2 outside farms, 2 extra peasants
PP progression: draft - heal - elves - EW - andùril - Cloudbreak - AotD - ents
creeps: 3/6



killed Lurtz 3 times
killed saru 2 times
King's favour ability of Theo
dryfire of Lurtz (I always like to c this uber-micro of heroes vs Lurtz )
good use of peasants (some spam in the beginning, then vs pikes)


lost Theo 5 (!) times ( )
lost Ara once
a bit too late stable, try it 1 farm earlier....after u have 3 farms in base and 2 outside go for stables right away



comments: A good game of u with some small mistakes. In the beginning u got a bit pushed back, but u managed with ur FU peomen to defy the isen army. Aragorn has helped a lot, but ur attack on his base failed. Still u got map control, but u lost it due to the lack of men fighting for u (Try to expand a bit more, outposts r a great help vs isen). In the end u lost the game, but tommy was playing very well afterwards.
rating: 6




tommynt

start: 2 furns, 2 mills
PP progression: WC - industry - palatir - TL - rain - balrog
creeps 3/6



extra labourers
killed theo 5 (!) times ( )
killed aragorn once
sneaky attack with the ram was pro imo
saru's experience ability (damn what was the english word for it?)


lost Lurtz 3 times
lost saru 2 times
right in the middle of the game u nearly had no army on the field, Grenness took the MC very easy
balrog use was not perfect, but that didn't decide the game in the end



comments: A very good game tbh. U really knew what u were doing and u did it well. It's a good game to show how u shall play as isen vs Rohan. In the beginning u were ahead, but then Grennie forced u to retreat, but u avoided the attack easily. The ending was very funny with the balrog in his base, and he needed just around 1 kill to get AotD. Finally he got it, pwned ur army, but that didn't change much, u got him down very fast. gg m8
rating: 7/10


match comments: A very good isen vs Rohan game for everyone who has problems in this matchup. Both players had a very good mixture of armies and showed us a high skill level. It's a very entertaining replay and some funny scenes r in it. Mostly balanced in the beginning with isen just a small step ahead, but the Rohan came up and nearly killed his whole army. Isen found back in the game and won the game with some very clever moves.
match rating: 6/10
entertainment rating: 7/10


attack on isen base
[attachmentid=150149]


small counter attack on rohan
[attachmentid=150150]

final battle
[attachmentid=150151]



promoted to RotW contender