Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] Shau vs B2P|MiLF

#11PlaTy  Nov 21 2006, 05:29 AM -
Awards:
Because you ppl smurf to much. Its only fair tbh
#12Mavs  Nov 21 2006, 06:05 AM -
lol? Everyone knows our rmufs by now sleep.gif
#13DunedainStriker  Nov 22 2006, 14:58 PM -
Members are allowed to rate replays, someone who watched it probably rated it a 5.

Mine btw smile.gif
#14Mavs  Nov 22 2006, 16:01 PM -
lol ok...well, can we get a review? biggrin.gif
#15DunedainStriker  Nov 23 2006, 03:09 AM -
Shauling(Mordor) vs. B2P|MiLF(Rohan)
Fords of Isen
Top: Shauling
Bottom: MiLF


Shauling(Mordor)

Strategy: Gollum > orc spam > trolls > drummers > FU combos
PP Progression: eye > tainted land > industry > darkness

Pros:
*got 3 mills at start
*scouted his base with a laborer
*countered his strat well

Cons:
*didn't get trees for your trolls (would help against heroes/rohirrim)

This was a good game by you. You managed not to make any huge mistakes, and you countered his strategy well. Your starting route was interesting and it got you that 3rd mill. My only real suggestion would be to get trees for your trolls, to help them vs. heroes and give them a wider attack radius vs. rohirrim and such. You clearly know what you are doing, so good luck in the future!

Shauling Overall Score: 6/10


B2P|MiLF(Rohan)

Strategy: Merry > Peasants > 3 Rohirrim > Eomer > Eowyn > RA > Theoden > 2 RA's > 3 Yeoman > Aragorn > Upgrades > Elves
PP Progression: draft > heal > andruil

Pros:
*got eomers LD
*good and interesting counter to trolls
*had a very solid middle game

Cons:
*didn't get 2nd starting farm
*lost a Rohirrim battalion to a tower, you should have retreated them
*lost heroes and Rohirrim
*should have gone peoman rather than RA's

You had an OK game. You didn't have the best early game. You probably didn't expect him to use Gollum to take the top mill, so just try to get there as quickly as possible. Also, don't lose Rohirrim to towers early, it is a pointless loss. Your middle game was very good, you countered his trolls very well, and took MC. From there you should have gone for peoman, rather than Rohirrim Archers, as the peasants in front will mean more protection and longer survival than with Rohirrim Archers. Heed my advice, and good luck in the future!

B2P|MiLF Overall Score: 5/10

This game proves that Rohan owns mid game in this matchup, and that Mordor's late game is very tough. Mildly entertaining with nice counters to trolls from Rohan.

Overall Score: 5/10
Entertainment: 5/10
#16DunedainStriker  Nov 23 2006, 04:06 AM -
Btw if you see your opponent start to use eomer+eowyn to counter your trolls, just keep some orcs with your trolls. When they throw spears, eat an orc, trolls are healed, gg no re.

Was reminded of that in a game vs. Gen tonight.
#17Mavs  Nov 23 2006, 11:24 AM -
But you cvan throw both spears at the same troll, and he's dead biggrin.gif
#18DunedainStriker  Nov 23 2006, 14:28 PM -
Nope, doesnt work. Two spears will kill 90% of a troll, then you have fight him a bit. You clearly werent the Rohan in this game.

***Alert*** Mavs is not MiLF !!!!! biggrin.gif biggrin.gif biggrin.gif
Reply to Comment