Battle for Middle Earth

just played this match and it is a pretty cool replay considering entertainment i guess....

hmmmm i dont want to spoil anything......

i just watched it and only FForwarded 2 min in mid game....

trying to learn rohan a bit......

it says Dunharrow, "letzte Wiederholung" (last replay in german) btw sorry for that....

The least you could do, if you had even a little bit of respect, is to name your opponant's name proper in that title of yours.

He's as much part of that replay as you are, yes?



Numenor

a mod will have to edit i guess

Nice match!!!

Full of ups and downs for both players.. Nice Balrog v AotD, Ents v Trolls, Lego and Ara lvl 10 and so on...
Some RR will have a great time watching it.
btw.. Mordor is sooooooooo OP'ed

that wasn´t a matter of respect....i just didnt remember his name!

My biggest comment is that it could have been over way sooner. When prepare was left with only one outpost, CrystalBlue seemed to want to mass an entire army to defeat it.

Also, not a major crit, but you had peasants standing next to open plots for very long portions of the game (in which you needed cash), without building farms. I know it's easy to start missing things when nazgul, haradrim, trolls, orcs and mumakil are spilling into your broken base.


It was really a very good game.
Heroes are a major problem for Mordor. Their units are either too weak or to slow to kill them.
Very good defense.

hmm 2 very positive comments and noone wants it?

K i know i'm not a RR but i'm working on that trying to stack up on reviews on replays. I hope i do this game some justice.

Maveric's Side Line Report


Rohan(Prepare))

Started: 2 farms in base + Merry
PP: Draft -> Heal -> Anduril -> Elven Allies -> Elven Wood -> Cloud Break -> AOTD -> Ents


Pro's

Good use of little Merry to kil workers at his mills, slowing down his economy abit
Hero mirco through out game was generally good, maybe once or twice forgot about them but generally good
Couldn't believe how good you were at keep aragorn and legolas live with all mumakil coming in the start
Using legolas well by taking out his trolls
Killing all his nazgul, love the fact legolas was in the ruined tower and you had aragorn running round and round taking out naz
Rank 10 Legoals
Reviving aragorn at your outpost
Getting AOTD before he got balrog(4 points before)
Lvl 10 Aragorn
Using AOTD to counter his balrog


Con's

Never rushed his citadel with Aragorn, this can really slow down his nazgull and you could have put alot of pressure on him
Took long to get decent army and left unit standing in base for long time
Mid to end game you let him control the whole left side of the map, causing surprise attack on you castle
You didn't switch your elves to swords when you were fighting catapults meaning they stand still to fire and you lost alot like this


Mordor(CrystalBlu3))

Started: Orc pit + gollum + and outside mill
PP:Tainted Land -> Eye of Sauron -> Industry -> Darkness -> Balrog

Pro's

Established early map control and maintain it to end
Surprise attack of his base from the back while his army was off attacking you, managed to take out citadal
Killing aragorn twice once near your base with trolls + catapults. Secong with mumakil and nazgul
Attacked his base with Mumakil, catapults, trolls from the left side while he was off to the north east end of the map, this force him to come defend his base
Second attack on base with Mumakil, catapults and nazgul all trying to kill aragorn was spectacular
Taking out his base shortly after killing aragorn
Notice you placed a group of orcs in side ruined tower to prevent him from using it to hide from nazgul like before good thinking
Brillant thinking to use catapults to take out his citadal of his base once he rebuild it to prvent hero's coming back
Winning the GAME

Con's

Chasing horses around map in early game with your troll, use troll to rather lay siege to his base force him to build tower slow his units down
Lost alot of mumakil to legolas in early game due to poor micro maybe you could have used mass trolls or haradrim in the beginning of the game since the mumakill leveled legolas quickly and gave him alot of PP
when you did have trolls you gave them rocks, trees would have worked better since it does more damage to hero's and is better against archers as well since he was using them
Could have used nazgull in mid/end game to atcck his base since he left it undefended
:twitch: Never used screech to chase away his archers that had no banner upgrades

To end i think this was an outstanding game loved to watch it had good points and there were some mistakes but both players but no doubt both players played well. Could have went either really fun to watch.

I rate this game a 6/10

I reccomend that a RR take a look at the replay

cmon guys now even a future RR did a unofficial review and no RR looks at it.....its a ROTW contender imo

the tide turns quite a few times

cmon kiltec....

We've been busy u know

I'll take a look at it