I watched this replay yesterday and I have to say it was very entertaining. Especially a pro play by dinn and major did it good too, but dinn was the better one this time. I can learn a lot from his rohan play cause I am also a rohan player.
Well i think those RR's know what they are rating and I think myself it is definately a 7 too. And you are just saying it's a 5, please give some arguments for that 5 of you....
micro from both camps in early-mid game was very poor.
several times dinn ran his horses right through major's pikes. however, major didn't have his pikes in formation so both parties fucked up there.
major went wargs V 2 high lvl bats of rohirrim and theo with GC? nono.
dinn lost ALL his rohirrim, lvl 7 and lvl 8 i think, + theo in perhaps the crappiest assault on an FoD base i have ever seen.
5.
unfortunately I have to agree with C43UX, I watched all 3 of ther Major/Dinn games and was dissapointed at the mistakes made...When I saw Dinn got a 9 with "Perfect" micro I wanted to watch, as I know Dinn, and he was far from "perfect" last I saw. These games imo were not worth a 7 or 8. They were quite slopily played and MANY mistakes were made, I've seen better replays that got a 5 or 6 then these, sorry for the negativity, but that is what I think. If you don't believe me I could watch one of them and post mistakes I notice.
