Watched this now, and i think both of you had a excellent micro in this match. In a so long and hard game, its normal that there are some mistakes. In my opinion its defenitly rotw, maybe silver. And its so risky and hard with Gandalf vs Lurtz.
It's too rediculous for words this game isn't a Golden replay, and that it's a 7 ONLY!
I have seen almost every gold replays today of isen vs gondor, exactly the same strat everywhere. And i can tell you none of them can top this replay. It was really excellent.
Strats on both sides were good, they were executed properly. Gondor started rax at the right moment. Put the pressure on the isen fort well, destroyed pit
Only one thing, if you rush an isen fort go with all your horse bats, he had hardly any units near to his fort. With elves + Gandi and 3 horse bats, you could have done a lot more damage to his base. Now you only managed to attack 1 tower at the time (easy for him to demolish in time).
again: this replay deserves at least an 8 and definatly to be a golden replay.
Wp guys,
This post has been edited by Topalov: Aug 25 2007, 22:08 PM
u
vgg