Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

[R] elder vs OoE

#1Keidy  Sep 6 2006, 17:43 PM -
Me and pay have been playing bad (at least i have) during the past week.

Feel free to check this out and comment on anything you think we should have done different, or things we can improve on.
Help is always appreciated.
Unfortunately, i was the first to go, so the game ends pretty abrupt, but pay dident stay for long after that, so nothing more to see realy. Game was over by then.

GG OoE btw.

[attachmentid=141267]
#2FelLbEasT'  Sep 7 2006, 20:18 PM -
Awards:
1. You played OoE.
2. You played in cw's.
3. You played against non sweeds there is no contaest.
#3Keidy  Sep 7 2006, 20:40 PM -
QUOTE(FelLbEasT' @ Sep 7 2006, 08:18 PM) *

1. You played OoE.
2. You played in cw's.
3. You played against non sweeds there is no contaest.


? eyebrow.gif
#4FelLbEasT'  Sep 7 2006, 20:56 PM -
Awards:
As my sainted mum once said, get 'em early enough and the possibliltys are endless.
Keidypro we havn't talked on xfire in aggeeesss.
#5Keidy  Sep 7 2006, 21:27 PM -
QUOTE(FelLbEasT' @ Sep 7 2006, 08:56 PM) *

As my sainted mum once said, get 'em early enough and the possibliltys are endless.
Keidypro we havn't talked on xfire in aggeeesss.


Thats cuz you havent been around in ages buddy sleep.gif wink.gif

ps. Still dont understand your first post thou post-13661-1143531603.gif
#6LiGhT`  Sep 7 2006, 21:51 PM -
Awards:
Mine, cus i ow Keidy 1
#7Mad^Monkey  Sep 7 2006, 22:15 PM -
QUOTE(FelLbEasT' @ Sep 7 2006, 09:56 PM) *

As my sainted mum once said, get 'em early enough and the possibliltys are endless.


Top film. thumb.gif
#8LiGhT`  Sep 9 2006, 00:55 AM -
Awards:
|Elder|TopGuN (Mordor) / |Elder|PayBack (Gondor)
v
[OoE]Godlike^ (Gondor) / [OoE]Coo^Lung (Isengard)

Map - Anorien



|Elder|TopGuN (Mordor)

BO- Pit, 3 mills

PP Selection- Land--> Eye--> Industry

Strat- Orc spam--> Trolls

|Elder|PayBack (Gondor)

BO- 2 farms in, Pippin, 1 farm out

PP Selection- Land--> Heal

Strat- Knights--> Horse shields--> Combos--> Upgrades


Pros
smile.gif Good harassment
smile.gif Teamwork - Sharing powers
smile.gif Good formation use
smile.gif Good defending early game

Cons
sad.gif Forgot to make your labs work again once you moved them
sad.gif Horse micro
sad.gif Map awareness - he was attacking/scouting you without you reacting a while

Comments- Your early game was good, but could of been better if PayBack sent 1 soldier to gondors farms and 1 soldiers to help defend. You knew he had nothing to defend against your soldiers, so only 1 batallion was needed. Once you got you horses out you should of reclaimed your farms back before attempting to harass his, either way he still has extra econ being produced on your side of the map. Once you seen that Gondor got upgrades for his knights, you should of also got upgrades, instead of combos. As you seen, the combos were useless and never actually got used = a waste of money which your desperatly needed. Mordor should of began building trolls earlier then he did, instead of hoping on getting the middle. When v Isen, it isnt the best choice of a faster middle due to the upgraded unit spam. My best advice to give you is either, search for another replays with this match up.... or you could ask Sage the Team SM for advice.

Rating- 4

___________________________________________


[OoE]Godlike^ (Gondor)

BO- 2 farms in, Pippin, 1 out

PP Selection- Land--> Heal

Strat- Knights--> Upgrades--> Horse shields

[OoE]Coo^Lung (Isengard)

BO- Pit, 3 mills

PP Selection- War chant--> Land

Strat- Uruks--> X-Bows--> Pikes--> Zerks--> Grades--> Combos--> middle


Pros
smile.gif Good formation use
smile.gif Scouting gondor base with labourer
smile.gif Teamwork
smile.gif Harassment
smile.gif Good creeping
smile.gif Good unit micro

Cons
sad.gif No suffiecient amount of towers in Isen castle throughout whole game
sad.gif Didn't attack Gondors econ early game

Comments- Your early was pretty good, and you certainly kept the pressure up on Mordor, however, Isen should of just spammed out uruks early game to help defend and attack in places all over the map. Once the knights/pikes were out, you kept your econ pretty well maintained and harassed their econ well. If isen went for an upgrade rush on Mordor with Gondors knights to back him up, you could of either won this game earlier or atleast crippled him bad enough to majorly slow his already delayed trolls. Excellent decision to spam some berserkers out to harass tbh....you dont normally see that in 2v2, it is normally only seen in 1v1 and 3v3. Nice harassment made by Gondor throughout the entire game kept Mordor and gondor unable to build a substantial army and he also managed to take the troll cage down without losing any knights! Pretty good game by you, and once you took the middle and pressed on, you had it in the bag.

Rating- 7

Final Comments

Pretty even game early on where you couldnt tell who had the advantage at the time. It was still pretty even towards the mid game, but was clear by end game who was winner. Gondor/Mordor need to win this game quick before Isen gets rain, otherwise gg.

Overall Rating- 5
Entertainment- 4/5


LiGhT`
This post has been edited by LiGhT`: Sep 9 2006, 00:58 AM
#9Keidy  Sep 9 2006, 07:30 AM -
Thnx m8, nice review thumb.gif
Reply to Comment