Explore GameReplays...

Battle for Middle Earth

Isen vs Gondor !

#31esa|TurtleTucke  Oct 21 2006, 13:58 PM -
Replays: 43 Game:
Awards:
U ask me or any other SRs/RRs ?? laugh.gif
If u ask me : SURE !!! I am glad if someone review this !! smile.gif
#32Blueb1rd  Oct 21 2006, 14:43 PM -
Awards:
I'll review it as my first application w00t.gif
#33esa|TurtleTucke  Oct 21 2006, 15:34 PM -
Replays: 43 Game:
Awards:
NICE ! wub.gif
#34Blueb1rd  Oct 21 2006, 16:16 PM -
Awards:
B2P|Fate vs esa|TurtleTucke
Gondor vs Isengard
Fords Of Isen
1.03


B2P|Fate (Gondor on top)
BO: 3 farms in 2 out --> stable --> BS --> 2 knights --> faramir --> combos
PP: Land --> Heal --> elves --> Rohhiram --> GTW --> Eagles --> AOD

Pros:
thumb.gif Used knights to beat pikes.
thumb.gif Elves summon used throught game to keep some map control.
thumb.gif Nice mirco in the main battle, using all summons at the same times.

Cons
sad.gif Didn't use a PP at the start early enough, should of healed soldiers at top.
sad.gif Only had 1 batt of cav for most of the game, poor map control at mid game.
sad.gif Quite useless rohhiram summon running into pikes
sad.gif No boromir
sad.gif Bought the GTW pp before gtw arrived, no WB available and he died very soon.

Notes: Played a good game, got an army fast and attacked his base right away which didn't let tucke build a strong army until you both swapped bases. Map control would of won the game earlier for you.

Rating - 7


esa|TurtleTucke (Isengard at bottom)
BO: Uruk Pit + furn --> 3 uruks,1 xbow, pike spam--> 5 furns --> Warg pit --> armoury
PP: warchant --> Palantir --> Industy --> Land --> Rain --> Fuel the fires

Pros:
thumb.gif Great uruk usage, defended mills nice.
thumb.gif Extra laborers.
thumb.gif Good map control throughout the game.
thumb.gif Used palantir to increase speed of units.
thumb.gif Killed gtw.

Cons
sad.gif Didn't use formation for starting uruks.
sad.gif Could of destroyed armoury faster.
sad.gif Not enough wargs, should of bough more.
sad.gif Didn't defend base with any units
sad.gif Could of used wormtongue to take control of all his army.
frusty.gif Didn't use rain for the main battle of the game.

Notes: Played a fairly new strat that was working quite good, it started going downhill when you lost a few batts of wargs and built uruks and didn't really need them, should of tried to defend base more. Try getting more wargs or fire combos. This was only of crusilidusili's 1st games of 1.03, after practice he will back to his best wub.gif

Rating - 6


Overall this was a gg by both sides and entertaining, bases were swapped and both players did good to stay alive. If there were more battles instead of running away from big fights the score would be higher.

Game rating - 6
Entertainment - 6

Rotw contender
This post has been edited by BluebirdMJ: Oct 21 2006, 16:27 PM
#35esa|TurtleTucke  Oct 21 2006, 16:23 PM -
Replays: 43 Game:
Awards:
Very nice review !!!
And i think i didnt defend my base coz he had fu combos+LS. I tohught i only have a chance if i sneak attack his base and it worked pretty good imo laugh.gif My Saroman use wasnt the best but i dunno if hes able to use his abilities before hes dead. Gondor had OP+LS+Statue so i didnt know if i can use Saroman next to those killer combos ^^
Thnx for review ! smile.gif
#36Guardian  Oct 22 2006, 00:43 AM -
Replays: 34 Game:
Awards:
The rating is now official btw biggrin.gif
Reply to Comment